Shadow Scale: A Companion to Seraphina - Rachel Hartman

 

Why is it so hard to write a good ending?  Is it just an author thing to write a cool story and then get all weird right at the end?

 

Shadow Scale, the follow up to the fantastic Seraphina, started slow, but quickly got going and was on its way to awesome.  Then the ending got weird.
 
Right at the moment when things could have crossed into book-immortality, Shadow Scale crumpled under the weight of its own potential.  And since the final book in a series (even if it’s only a series of two) holds the responsibility for putting a bow on the bigger story, a failure here diminishes what the entire series could have been.

 

The good guys didn’t get what they wanted.  The bad guys didn’t get what they deserved.  The lovers didn’t get love.  The best character relationship didn’t get closure for its conflict.  The reveals we spent 1200 pages trying to solve were anticlimactic.  The biggest mystery of all was ignored and left unanswered.

 

So ya, not happy with this one.  All because of the ending.  Dang.

 

When I grow up and write my own books, they are all going to have AWESOME endings.

 

The Value of a Star: Ratings Explained